Tuesday, July 28, 2020

"How the Child Care Crisis Will Distort the Economy for a Generation"

You can read the rest of this article here, but here are some of the main points:

"Stevenson: I’ve been really struck by how much the federal government scrambled to save the airlines — “Oh, wouldn’t it be terrible for our economy if we lost all our airlines?” I guess it wouldn’t be great. But how terrible would it be for our economy if we lost all our child care and our schools? That would be way worse than losing our airlines! That would leave not only the current working generation unable to go back to work in the same way, it would mean that we are not preparing the next generation so that they have skills. I mean, it is so substantially worse than losing your airlines. And yet we gave less money to the entire child care sector than we gave to one single airline, Delta. I don’t mean to pick on Delta, but it seems crazy that we care more about saving Delta Airlines than we do about the entire child care industry.





Child care is one of those issues where we still really think it’s a personal problem: ‘You made the choice to have those little rugrats. You deal with them.’ Compare that with elder care. We recognized it was a social issue. We built a series of nursing homes and institutional care, and we have societal grants to cover some of that through Medicaid. But with child care, we’ve said this isn’t a social issue. And I think the pandemic has revealed that it is a social issue.

. . .

. . . You’re seeing child care centers that can’t stay in business. They can’t figure out how to reopen. They can’t keep their employees on staff. They’re letting people go. I see a world where we’re all vaccinated by next spring, and we’re ready to have every kid back in child care, back in school, back at camp — but now they’re starting from scratch, recruiting workers because all their workers have sort of disappeared or moved on. Some of them have gotten other jobs and are never coming back. Others have decided that they’re retiring early. Others have moved physically — ‘Yeah, maybe I worked with children before, and I’m ready to do that again. But I’ve never worked with this employer.’ So how do they make that match? That’s a slow process."



The lack of child care will take away "choice" from so many parents, mainly women, forcing many mothers back into full-time (or at least part-time daytime) parenting for lack of an alternative. As a consequence, much of what my generation fought for in the Women's Liberation Movement will be lost. 😢 Is "kinde, kuche, kirche" (children, kitchen, church--pardon my rotten German spelling) going to be women's only option all over again? Must anatomy be destiny? And if the continuity of the human species is so important, why do the people who perpetuate humanity get so little respect and have so little to show for it in our old age? Must parenthood make one poor?

3 Comments:

Blogger Coyote said...

Maybe we should have robots do a lot of our child care? ;) Of course, the technology might unfortunately not be there yet. :(

Anyway, hopefully the worst of this crisis will be over in a year or two. Then things might slowly be able to return to normal.

BTW, it doesn't have to be women who take care of the children. Rather, men could be stay-at-home dads while women work.

Also, FWIW, I responded to you in the 2009 patrilineal thread something like two weeks ago:

http://onthefringe_jewishblog.blogspot.com/2009/10/p-i-discuss-patrilineal-descent.html#comments

I suppose that this topic is sort-of on point here given shifting gender roles over the last several decades. ;)

Fri Jul 31, 11:03:00 PM 2020  
Blogger Shira Salamone said...

"hopefully the worst of this crisis will be over in a year or two. Then things might slowly be able to return to normal."

Coyote, the whole point of this article is that so many daycare providers are shutting down because they can't afford to stay open without any income that "normal" will no longer exist by the time this pandemic is over. :(

"BTW, it doesn't have to be women who take care of the children. Rather, men could be stay-at-home dads while women work."

That decision may depend on which spouse has the higher income.

Mon Aug 03, 05:13:00 PM 2020  
Blogger Coyote said...

Can't daycare providers theoretically eventually reopen and begin re-attracting customers once this pandemic is over, though? I mean, it's similar to how Souplanation can theoretically reopen once this pandemic will be over, no?

Also, Yes, the decision in regards to who gets to be the stay-at-home parent could very well depend on which parent has the higher income.

Tue Aug 18, 07:26:00 PM 2020  

Post a Comment

<< Home

<< List
Jewish Bloggers
Join >>